James Nicoll Reviews

Home > Reviews > Post

Like the Trembling Heart of a Captive Bird

Shards of Honor  (Cordelia Vorkosigan, volume 1)

By Lois McMaster Bujold 

19 Jan, 2018

A Bunch of Bujolds

12 comments

Support me with a Patreon monthly subscription!

Lois McMaster Bujold’s 1986 debut novel Shards of Honor is the first Cordelia Vorkosigan book, as well as the first novel set in Bujold’s Vorkosiverse.

A Betan exploratory mission has been sent through a newly discovered wormhole; they have discovered a terrestrial world suitable for colonization. Unfortunately for the Betans, they are the second group to discover Sergyar. The Barrayaran militarists were there first and they don’t want company.



Cordelia and her co-worker Dubauer return from a field trip to find that the Betan shuttle has taken off without them. Not only that, the Betan base camp has been reduced to smouldering ruins, in which they find the corpse of one of the Betan officers. Worse than that … it seems that not all of the attackers are gone. A sudden attack gravely wounds Dubauer and knocks out Cordelia.

Cordelia wakes to find herself the prisoner of the notorious Barrayaran officer, Aral Vorkosigan. Aral is widely believed to be responsible for a mass execution on a newly conquered planet. As Cordelia finds out, what the galaxy thinks happened and what actually happened are quite different. Aral does not appear to be the monster he is painted in the popular press. 

Nominally the commanding officer of the Barrayaran expedition, Aral was himself ambushed by his subordinates and left for dead at the Betan camp. The mutineers made the error of entrusting the job of killing Aral to the troubled Sergeant Bothari, who cannot bring himself to kill Aral. Much much more on Bothari in later books in the Vorkosiverse. 

A new habitable world is valuable in itself. To Barrayar, the system’s true value lies in the second wormhole in the system, the one that leads to the Escobar system. The pro-war faction in the Barrayaran government believe that if they can control the wormhole, they can mount a surprise attack on Escobar. Moar planets! Moar glory!

Smart money might say that Aral and Cordelia’s budding romance is doomed by the fact they are officers on opposite sides of an interstellar war. The smart money would be wrong. Fate will bring them back together. 

~oOo~

Jim Baen liked this novel enough to buy it and two other LMB novels1. This is how a political troglodyte like Baen came to publish Ethan of Athos , a novel about a planet populated exclusively by gay men. He did finally get around to reading it, which is why if internet rumour can be believed, there was never a sequel to Ethan .

There’s a lot of off-stage rape and on-stage near-rape in this book. LMB isn’t exactly subtle about giving readers clear signals about who the bad guys are, so the pro-war party isn’t just pro-war2. It’s also a collection of spineless yes-men and murderous sadists. But the war party is led by Crown Prince Serg, who is as bad as any of his followers, but too well connected to be squelched, what with being the son of the Emperor and all. Serg is all set to be one more of Barrayar’s insane and cruel rulers. This poses something of a problem for his entirely sane father.

Me, I just cannot fathom what Cordelia and Aral see in each other. The romance seems to proceed much too quickly, for reasons that are unclear to me. [Editor’s note: this is romance genre stuff. This is the meet-cute of all meet-cutes. You have not read sufficient bodice-rippers. ] Surely Cordelia’s affections could be more constructively bestowed on someone who isn’t a highly placed officer in a brutal militaristic state. But SF does love its autocrats and as far as autocrats go, Aral looks pretty good next to Serg. 

Shards of Honor is available here (Amazon). If Chapters or Kobo have this edition, their crappy search engines successfully hid it from me.

1: Something I only discovered while researching this review. Ethan of Athos was submitted to Terry Carr at Ace. for a line he was then editing specifically for first novels.”

He would have been overseeing the third series of Ace Specials. Had Carr beat Baen to the punch, Ethan of Athos might have been published alongside novels like The Wild Shore and Neuromancer . But probably not, because Carr seems to have had a blind spot where women authors were concerned. Of the twelve novels in the third Ace Specials, only one, O’Keefe’s Black Snow Days , was by a woman.

2: This novel does not spend a lot of time on Barrayaran history. We learn later that Barrayar had a reason for invading Komarr that was not just greedy imperialism. Komarr controls the only wormhole that leads to Barrayar. Komarr previously allowed the Cetagandans to invade Barrayar, which provoked a vicious guerrilla war and ended in Cetagandan defeat. Barrayar has a good reason to make sure that they are never invaded again. 

But invading Escobar is just plain imperialism.