James Nicoll Reviews

Home > Reviews > Post

Come Back Even Stronger

Magical Women

Edited by Sukanya Venkatraghavan 

4 Oct, 2019

Doing What the WFC Cannot Do


Support me with a Patreon monthly subscription!

Sukanya Venkatraghavan’s 2019 Magical Women is a speculative fiction anthology that showcases a few of India’s best women writers.

Gul” by Shreya Ila Anasuya

An aged woman once a courtesan, now a professional singer and married woman, tells how she met the love of her lifeduring the bloody aftermath of the Indian Rebellion of 1857. Decades later, the story had an unexpected sequel. 

Gandaberunda” by S.V. Sujatha 

Men saw Amaya as easily seduced or at least easily forced. Her twin Anani saw men as deserving prey. Anani was never far from Amaya. 

Rulebook For Creating A Universe” by Tashan Mehta

The people of the island are charged with creating new universes, a process guided by a detailed and inflexible rulebook. An idealist young woman sets out to correct a systemic error in their method. Too bad for her that this society abhors innovation and innovators. Particularly if they are women stepping out of their ordained roles.

The Demon Hunter’s Dilemma” by Samhita Arni 

Sent out by her beloved guru to stalk and capture the monsters who fill the Hasdeo Arand forest, Antara begins to doubt. How does she know what her teacher has told her is true? 

Earth And Evolution Walk Into A Bar…” by Sejal Mehta

A cruel and self-centred mankind tests the limits of the Earth’s tolerance and finds them. 


It’s not a coincidence that I use the word mankind” and not humanity” in the previous lines. 

Tridevi Turbulence” by Trisha Das 

Faced with the fact that embracing their traditional roles means being exploited by men, goddesses conclude that the only winning move is not to play the game at all.

Stone Cold” by Kiran Manral 

The Brotherhood had a crystal clear vision of humanity’s future. Their inflexible, authoritarian vision failed to account for the desires of mortal flesh — and the wishes of forgotten gods.

The Gatekeeper’s Intern” by Ruchika Roy 

What seemed to be a near-death experience was in fact an actual death experience followed by a resurrection. The survivor may attain godlike status … if they are willing to accept godlike responsibility.

Grandma Garam’s Kitty Party” by Shweta Taneja

Tired of life as a Chudail, Jaanu yearns to become a normal human woman. Conformity comes at a price that Jaanu may not be willing to pay. 

The Carnival At The Edge Of The Worlds” by Shveta Thakrar 

Prajakta embraces the adage know thyself.” She succeeds, at a cost. 

The Rakshasi’s Rose Garden” by Sukanya Venkatraghavan

The rakshasi who lives in Apartment 606 A tends a garden. From time to time she presents her gossiping neighbours with extra-special gifts.

Bahameen” by Asma Kazi 

A time traveler is trapped in a particularly unpleasant version of Earth, one with features that make escape both impossible and inconceivable. 

The Girl Who Haunted Death” by Nikita Deshpande 

Legend says Savitri stalked Death until Savitri’s beloved husband was resurrected. Legend leaves out important details.…

Apocalyptica” by Krishna Udayasankar 

Mankind is irredeemable. Nor is it immune to a vengeance undertaken by motivated goddesses.

General comments

Most of the stories feature gods and goddesses, even the stories set in the future. 

The editor’s introduction makes the collection sound optimistic. It is not. Many of the stories explore sexism, injustice, resistance, and revenge. A few stories make the case for burning down the world. 

The authors are angered by the state of their world. This does not prevent their stories from being finely told and skillfully shaped. Anger has honed craft, which makes the stories eminently readable even when they break one’s heart. 

If you found Jemisin’s Broken Earth trilogy too optimistic, consider this anthology. 

Magical Women is available here (Amazon), here (Amazon.ca), and here (Chapters-Indigo).