James Nicoll Reviews

Home > Reviews > Post

Tell Me Lies

The Cosmic Computer

By H. Beam Piper 

7 Apr, 2019

Because My Tears Are Delicious To You

6 comments

Support me with a Patreon monthly subscription!


H. Beam Piper’s 1963 The Cosmic Computer is a standalone science fiction novel. It’s set in Piper’s Terra-Human future history, in the last days of the Federation. 

Conn Maxwell returns from Terra to his backwater homeworld, Poictesme, armed with hard-won knowledge. The family friends who pooled resources to pay for Conn’s education did so in the hope that while on Earth, Conn would uncover the secret location of Merlin, the fabled supercomputer that many believe allowed the Federation to triumph over the secessionist System States Alliance. With Merlin’s help, surely the investors could learn how to kickstart Poictesme’s moribund economy. 

What Conn learned was that Merlin was not just legendary. It was a myth. There would be no all-powerful supercomputer to guide Poictesme to prosperity. 

When Conn returns to his homeworld, he lies to his friends and backers. He claims to know how to find Merlin. This isn’t just an attempt to spare his friends or evade responsibility for the failure. He wants to use the belief in Merlin to inspire his world to take the steps that will rebuild its economy. 




Poictesme and its associated systems served as a Federation advance base during the war. When the war ended, Federation calculated that their facilities weren’t worth salvaging. The Federation mothballed them [1] and left. 

People like Conn’s father have made a living from salvaging what the Federation abandoned. Other Poictesmians are farmers. Both salvagers and famers make only mediocre livings; they sell to middlemen, who make the real profits. Conn’s notion is to power up the shipbuilding facilities the Federation abandoned. When Poictesme can build its own hyper-capable ships [2], it will have direct access to off-world markets. The thousand percent mark-ups the traders enjoy will go into the pockets of the people of Poictesme. 

Great if it works. But if Conn’s plan doesn’t work, and if the people of Poictesme learn they’ve been tricked, Conn could be in a lot of trouble. 

~oOo~

Nothing says wholesome adventure fare for teens than a guy’s head exploding. 


I don’t have my copy of Carr’s biography of Piper handy to check but I think this may be the novel that scuttled Piper’s career. As I recall, the book saw print before serialization thanks to error on the part of Piper’s literary agent. Piper missed out on the magazine income … which there would have been, as The Cosmic Computer is just the sort of Lie-That-Came-True story John W. Campbell loved. Piper desperately needed that income. 

When I first read this book, I hadn’t read the biography … nor had I learned that Piper took a romantic view of the Confederacy. In that light, the robot servants who frequently appear in the narrative are unpleasantly reminiscent of slavery. Protagonist Conn’s equips his mother’s domestic robots with

recorded-voice responses in a thick Sheshan accent. All the smart people on Terra, he explained, had Sheshan humanoid servants.

On the other hand, the fact that the people of Poictesme have been content to yearn for the lost golden age without doing anything constructive to recover it suggests that Piper did not have entirely flattering views of his fellow fans of the so-called Lost Cause. It takes a college-educated man to set things right on Poictesme. 

Piper would also have disappointed fans of the Lost Cause by his tendency to emphasize that this is the future by giving his characters non-Anglo names like Lorenzo Menardes, Kurt Fawzi, and Len Yeniguchi. Piper wrote meat-and-potato science fiction, of the sort that appealed to readers of Astounding/Analog , but his take on ethnic diversity was distinctly progressive. 

His take on women was also atypical. Piper was (with James Schmitz) one of the few Astounding authors to see women (whom he called girls) as competent in their own right. They didn’t just make token appearances so that the protagonists could ogle them while infodumping at them. At one point Conn is in need of technicians. It falls to Sylvie Jacquemont to point out the women workers that men like Conn don’t see: 

If you expect to get any kind of a gang together, at least a third of them will be girls. A lot of technicians are girls, and when work gets slack, they’re always the first ones to get shoved out of jobs. I’ll bet there are a thousand girl technicians out of work here — any line of work you want to name. 

In these modern days, when only techbros, conservative politicians, and other bottom-feeders are astounded to learn women are people, this may not seem like such an unusual speech, but in 1963, this was an atypical stance for a male author to take. 

Does Conn’s bold plan work? Well, that would be telling. 

The Cosmic Computer is available here (Gutenberg).

1: The items the Fed left behind include weapons that make our nukes look like hand grenades. They’re there for the taking by ambitious would-be warlords with space ships. This is how you get Space Vikings. 


2: For some reason Piper imagined utterly enormous starships. Each freighter could hold a significant fraction of the US’s industrial output. It’s not clear why they have to be so huge or exactly WHAT will fill those echoing holds.